alles muss raus - mit Thilo Mischke · Pqpp2 Audio

#amr_buchklub: Worth the hype? Lázár von Nelio Biedermann

January 30, 2026·1 hr 18 min·6 clips
Thilo confesses he started 'Lazar' three times, questioning if he's 'too dumb' for this hyped novel.
1. The 'alles muss raus' book club episode features Thilo Mischke, Coco Meurer, and Kathi discussing 'Lazar,' the debut novel by 22-year-old Nelio Biedermann. 2. Thilo hosts; Coco and Kathi are regular book club participants, with Kathi noted as someone who typically abandons books mid-read — she finished this one. 3. The central question is whether 'Lazar' justifies its intense literary hype, which includes a blurb by Daniel Kehlmann described as 'Ritterschlag des Todes' (the highest possible endorsement). 4. 'Lazar' is a family saga following an aristocratic family through 20th-century upheavals — revolution, World War II, expropriation, and flight — told across multiple generations. 5. The novel is unusually compact for its genre: all three hosts remark on how thin the book is given that it covers a family across generations, a format that typically produces very thick volumes. 6. Thilo read the opening section three times and called his friend Gibran mid-read to ask who the character Imre was, ultimately concluding he may not be the book's target audience. 7. Coco and Kathi both also made character lists and used ChatGPT to map the family tree before the recording, citing the novel's rapid time jumps and large cast as disorienting. 8. Thilo's main critical verdict: 'Lazar' has enormous production value — he uses the Cirque du Soleil metaphor — but after finishing, he could recall only one sentence, leaving him feeling the book was 'written for effect.' 9. He describes Biedermann as aware of being 23 and using his youth as a performance: 'der Autor nutzt sein Alter, um diese Sprache zu sprechen, um diesen zirkusartigen Moment eines Artisten zu erleben.' 10. Coco pushes back: she found the book's prose genuinely beautiful and was impressed by Biedermann's ability to create atmosphere per chapter, even if the characters felt thin. 11. Kathi introduces the comparison to Jenny Erpenbeck's 'Die Heimsuchung,' which follows a house in Brandenburg over 150 years and handles similar themes — sexual violence, the Second World War, East German socialism — but left her annotating every page. 12. The group debates whether 'Lazar' is a 'Beach Read' masquerading as high literature: Thilo insists it is; Coco disagrees, arguing the book is genuinely demanding despite its surface accessibility. 13. Thilo characterizes the book's ideal reader as someone in their mid-60s who once kept a Max Frisch paperback in their jeans pocket at graduation — nostalgic for a certain kind of literary performance. 14. The group's most sustained debate concerns the novel's depictions of female sexuality, particularly the sexual awakening of a character named Ilona at the novel's opening, which struck several readers as dissonant. 15. Kathi argues that Biedermann addresses this directly: a full chapter is given to character Eva reading Virginia Woolf's 'A Room of One's Own' and reflecting on how male authors including Kafka have depicted women. 16. Multiple readers said their discomfort was partly shaped by knowing the author's face and age: 'Ich habe das Buch gelesen mit dem Gedanken, das hat gerade ein 22-Jähriger geschrieben.' 17. The hosts agree the book's formal style — heavily nested sentences, rapid time jumps, a fairy-tale narrative register — places unusual demands on a casual reader and would likely alienate non-regular readers if marketed as easy. 18. Chapters 18, 19, and 20 generate discussion because they appear to have the narrator speaking directly to the reader as a writer, breaking from the family narrative in a way that struck some readers as an unauthorized intrusion. 19. People who enjoy dense European literary fiction, debate about contemporary German-language authors, or feminist readings of family sagas will find the conversation substantive. 20. Listeners who haven't read 'Lazar' and aren't familiar with Daniel Kehlmann, Jenny Erpenbeck, or the contemporary German literary scene may find some references opaque.
Listen to the show on