All2ReelToo - A Pop Culture Podcast · All2ReelToo | The Geek Collective | Cullen Park Productions

It: Chapter Two (2019) - BASED ON THE WORKS OF STEPHEN KING

February 12, 2026·56 min·3 clips

Jessica Chastain, James McAvoy, and Bill Hader headline an adult Losers Club built around fear and trauma.

1. All2ReelToo covers It Chapter Two, the 2019 sequel based on Stephen King’s It. 2. Michael E. Cullen II hosts with Sesame in Carta, and their shared book-and-movie comparison drives the discussion. 3. The episode asks why the Losers Club returns to Derry after 27 years and how Andy Muschietti adapts that reunion. 4. The hosts name Jessica Chastain, James McAvoy, Bill Hader, Isaiah Mustafa, Jay Ryan, and the younger returning cast. 5. They also warn listeners that the conversation includes suicide and domestic violence. 6. Michael says James Ransone, who plays adult Eddie Kasparak, had recently died in real life. 7. The IMDb logline they read says the Losers Club had grown up and moved away before a devastating phone call brings them back. 8. They talk about Pennywise, Bill Skarsgard’s performance, and the film’s stronger emphasis on action than on psychology. 9. Sesame says the movie is “super, super scary” and explains that gore makes it hard for him to watch. 10. The hosts suggest watching Welcome to Derry after the two It films because it adds context to Pennywise and Derry. 11. Michael explains that people who leave Derry for a long time start forgetting their years there. 12. They discuss Mike Hanlon staying in Derry, which leaves him with the clearest memories of the group. 13. They compare the film’s ritual of Chud with the book’s more abstract version and the idea of collecting artifacts. 14. Michael describes Beverly’s apartment fears, including the old woman who becomes a grotesque monster. 15. They connect Ben’s memory of Beverly to the yearbook page he kept in his wallet for 27 years. 16. The hosts note that Bill’s job as a writer lets the movie joke that his endings “suck.” 17. Michael and Sesame keep the tone conversational and observational, with frequent side comments and book comparisons. 18. Their pacing is loose and anecdotal, with several detours into trivia, casting, and Stephen King references. 19. Fans of Stephen King adaptations and film-versus-book breakdowns. 20. Viewers wanting a spoiler-heavy plot recap of the ending.

As heard by us

A loose, King-nerd conversation that turns adaptation trivia into easygoing horror talk.

This episode uses the conversation to turn King adaptation talk into the main event, not just a verdict on any one movie. Michael E. Cullen II and Sesame bounce from Pennywise jokes to the book’s huge page count, the audiobook, and the way King stories keep changing when they…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a Pennywise chat that keeps drifting into King-canon detours?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from All2ReelToo - A Pop Culture Podcast