Alabama Prison Reform Proposal · R. L. Robinson

Promoted for Death: Alabama’s $51 Million Cover-Up and the Forgotten Prison Crisis

·13 min·1 clip

Alabama spent $51 million defending officers from misconduct lawsuits while violence escalated.

This episode investigates Alabama's prison system, using evidence from the HBO documentary "The Alabama Solution" and other sources. Hosts analyze systemic failures, unconstitutional conditions, and a documented lack of accountability that has persisted for decades. The Alabama Department of Corrections houses roughly 20,000 people in facilities running at nearly 200% capacity with only one-third of necessary staff. The documentary began in 2019 when filmmakers gained access to Easterling Correctional Facility but were expelled after incarcerated men risked punishment to report beatings and squalid conditions. A six-year investigation then relied on evidence from contraband cell phones smuggled by officers. Leaders of the Free Alabama Movement, like Robert Earl Council (Kinetic Justice) and Melvin Ray, used these phones to capture and share photos and videos. Their footage revealed rat-infested cells, piles of human waste from failed plumbing, rotting food, and blood-streaked floors. The Free Alabama Movement is a grassroots group demanding basic human rights and leveraging the economic power of prison labor to force change. Use of force incidents in ADOC facilities increased by 47% over the last decade while the prison population dropped by 4,000 people. Since 2020, Alabama has settled 94 lawsuits alleging excessive force and spent $51 million in five years just to defend officers from misconduct lawsuits. In a 2018 incident at Donaldson, a 145-pound prisoner suffered broken ribs and a collapsed lung after a 300-pound officer kneeled on his back, with a supervisor's report claiming only minimum force was used. Stephen Davis was beaten to death by officers in 2019, with eyewitnesses testifying he yielded immediately despite the state's official story. Officer Roderick Gadsen, reportedly involved in Davis's death and named in over 20 excessive force lawsuits, was promoted to lieutenant twice afterward. The prison labor system provides about $450 million annually in goods and services to the state, with incarcerated workers making $2 a day, a wage set in 1927. Incarcerated individuals who work are statistically less likely to receive parole than those who don't, and overall parole rates in Alabama have dropped by 72%. In 2020, the Department of Justice sued ADOC, citing systematic violence and unconstitutional conditions, which Governor Kay Ivey rejected as federal overreach. Governor Ivey's "Alabama Solution" involved diverting $400 million in federal COVID-19 relief funds and $100 million from the state's education budget to build three new prisons. In October 2022, Kinetic Justice and Melvin Ray led an 11-day statewide prisoner work stoppage, which ADOC broke through reports of mass starvation, physical abuse, and intimidation by tactical teams. The episode suggests the financial costs of lawsuits and federal scrutiny are seen by some as a necessary expense for maintaining a lucrative, low-wage workforce. It questions if Alabama's model of secrecy, denial, and force reflects a broader American approach where accountability is stripped away. The tone is investigative and conversational, blending documentary analysis with data-driven reporting to expose institutional failures. Listeners interested in criminal justice reform, investigative journalism, and systemic government accountability will find this episode compelling. Those seeking lighter content or who are uncomfortable with graphic descriptions of violence and human suffering may choose to skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Alabama Prison Reform Proposal