ADR - Episode 619: 2412 E Cochrane Rd

·1 hr 24 min·5 clips

Marley sees a tall, writhing figure with needle teeth emerge from the darkness of the antiquated bathroom.

The episode begins with the hosts introducing themselves and the story '2412 East Cochrane Road' by MMPratt99, which they are covering as prep for the author's Aberration series. They provide a rundown of the plot: on April 1st, Ralphie needs the bathroom but finds it locked with something mimicking his sister Lisa inside, while later his sister Marley witnesses a terrifying skeletal figure there. The hosts then move into their 'Grand Inquisitions' segment, critiquing grammatical errors like run-on sentences and misplaced commas. They analyze the story's setting in Curtisville, noting its magical realism elements like licornes and references to Norse mythology. The hosts discuss the story's strengths, such as relatable sibling dynamics and the creepy concept of a ghost gaslighting the family. However, they criticize the narrative structure, particularly the confusing transition between Ralphie's and Marley's perspectives, which some feel creates unnecessary whiplash. They debate whether the story's ambiguity adds to the horror or detracts from cohesion. The hosts also appreciate the included images that visualize elements like Dutch colonial architecture and 'handalabras.' In final thoughts, all three hosts give partial recommendations, suggesting the story as a good entry point to Curtisville tales but needing refinement in its ending and scene transitions. The episode concludes with promotional details and credits.

As heard by us

A context-first horror chat that makes setup work feel useful.

Al Dente Rigamortis treats 2412 East Cochrane Road as a setup piece, and the real draw is the panel's steady work through the linked names, the sequel, Gerald's voice, the self-harm mention, the troll-and-ogre logic, and the question of whether Curtisville has power lines.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Play this if you want a creepypasta discussion that stays critically silly and only half off the fence.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Al Dente Rigamortis