playnext.fm

After Party

Phoebe Bridgers - Punisher ALBUM REVIEW | Music

·1 hr 17 min·5 clips
Jaye drinks boxed wine from a mason jar while debating why Powerade Zero is superior to Gatorade Zero.
The episode begins with hosts Jaye Williams and Brando Hall engaging in humorous, off-topic banter about drinking boxed wine from a mason jar and debating the merits of Powerade Zero versus Gatorade Zero. They briefly touch on topics like the movie 'Call Me By Your Name' and air a listener apology regarding political comments. The show then transitions to music discussion, starting with a segment on recent singles. They review tracks from Acceptance, Sway Lee, Always Never, Alicia Keys, and The Killers, offering opinions on each. Jaye highlights Acceptance's new song 'Cold Air' for its synth sounds and maturity, while Brando criticizes Sway Lee's 'Reality Check' as garbage. The hosts disagree on Alicia Keys' 'Perfect Way to Die,' with Brando finding it powerful and Jaye criticizing its theatrical production. The core of the episode is a review of Phoebe Bridgers' new album 'Punisher.' Both hosts share their history with her music, noting how they discovered her debut 'Stranger in the Alps.' Brando expresses initial nervousness about the sophomore album but ultimately declares it his album of the year, praising its songwriting and feeling of familiarity. Jaye offers a more critical take, stating he likes but doesn't love the album, feeling it plays it safe and lacks progression in parts, though he acknowledges standout tracks like 'Savior Complex' and 'I Know the End.' They debate the expectations for singer-songwriters and genre progression, with Brando comparing Phoebe Bridgers to classic artists and Jaye wanting more innovation. The hosts discuss production quality, with Jaye noting the excellent instrumentation but feeling it takes a backseat to vocals. They end with final grades: Brando gives an A, and Jaye gives a B. The episode closes with promotional mentions for their Twitch streams and other content.

As heard by us

A loose, opinionated music argument about Killers fandom, Springsteen worship, and refusing required listening.

Jay Williams and Brando Hall turn a music conversation into a relaxed but pointed argument about taste, fandom, and the long shadow of Bruce Springsteen worship.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play when you want music debate with a sharp opinion and absolutely no fear of a detour.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on
Apple PodcastsSpotify
Play clips from this episodeMore from After Party