Advantage | A 5e Dungeons & Dragons Podcast · Darkmore Podcast Network

3.21 | Plans and Holes

·1 hr 2 min·4 clips
Agnar fails the save and drops into the elemental silt after being shoved toward the hole.
1. Advantage's Plans and Holes centers on the party's attempt to collapse siege works near Underfjall while protecting Fitska's Runestone and the King's Highway. 2. Zach plays Lariskel Dream, Yessi plays Grimton Steadyhand, Steven plays Urshan Bethethnash, and Sarah plays Agnarr Elfbreaker, while Zaz appears as the group's contracted note-taking imp. 3. The episode's thesis is a tactical actual-play built around flashback planning, with the DM asking the players to set goals before they execute the action. 4. The recap places the Huntress below the Fords of Finjaska, where an earthquake opened a tunnel into the Underdark and the group decided to help Fitska become Jarl of Endelfilk. 5. Zaz maps the job into four objectives: protect the runestone, collapse Underfjall and the staged siege weapons, close the southbound King's Highway tunnel, and preserve the northbound route toward Fenjosgofilk. 6. The players debate whether to blow up the tunnel, bury the orcs, or reshape the ground into a ramp that drops ballistae, trebuchets, catapults, battering rams, and siege towers into the hole. 7. Grimton keeps the runestone, and the table repeatedly notes that the stone is heavy enough to impose disadvantage on physical checks. 8. Zaz warns that the tunnel is a thin place between realms and that the wrong explosion could reroute the Heaving Beck or drain the Darkest Deep. 9. The warning expands into a map-level explanation that the river feeds the Fjords of Finjaska, Svikolodom, Nagafilk, and Endelfilk. 10. The group explicitly compares the current mission to a previous heist where flashback planning was used to solve problems after the fact. 11. The party stealths in while orcs respond to sinkholes and watch siege towers disappear into the opening. 12. Steven and Zach combine their earth-moving magic to turn the ground into a slope that sends twelve siege towers crashing in together. 13. The resulting collapse traps or crushes orcs already in the hole and turns the opening into a spike pit. 14. Zaz then pushes Agnarr toward the opening, and Agnarr fails a Dexterity save and falls into the elemental silt below. 15. Grimton tries rope support, but the scene turns stranger when the hole's position keeps changing relative to the party and the floor feels non-Euclidean. 16. The players describe the realm beneath them as elemental silt, with pressure shifting underfoot and silt seeming to manifest from nowhere. 17. The tone mixes tactical Dungeons and Dragons planning, DM warnings, and table jokes about ropes, buttholes, and mining charges. 18. The format is collaborative and interruption-heavy, with the DM pausing for decisions and the players constantly reworking the earth-moving plan. 19. Listeners who like rules-light fantasy tactics, collaborative planning, and chaotic set pieces will get the most from it. 20. Listeners wanting a linear combat recap with no engineering talk may skip it.

As heard by us

A siege plan turns into improvised earthbending, miniature-building jokes, and Zach's suspicious murder talk.

Plans and Holes turns a tabletop fantasy objective into a brisk comic exercise in tactical improvisation. The party is working through a proving meant to help Fitska become the Jarl of Skuld of Endelfilk, and the route runs through stealth, siege weapons, and a very large hole…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get siege towers, improvised earthbending, and a plan that keeps finding new names for how bad it is.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on