A Whole Life Later · Wrongful Convictions Collective

9 - A Man is Simply a Man, Not a God

November 8, 2024·47 min·20 clips

Charles Smith's rise and fall sit at the center of this episode. The story begins with his early life in Toronto, where he was put up for adoption three months after birth and raised in a family that moved often because his father served in the Canadian Armed Forces. He spent years looking for his biological mother, eventually calling her on her 65th birthday. By 1999, The Fifth Estate was describing Smith as one of four Canadians with rare expertise in forensic child pathology. For 24 years, he worked at Toronto's Hospital for Sick Children and conducted more than a thousand child autopsies, while overseeing or assisting on even more. That authority is the problem. The episode then turns to a disturbing cluster of deaths in a children's hospital cardiac ward. Nurses raised the alarm as the numbers climbed, but doctors and supervisors first blamed the children's medical conditions. One death came in June, five more followed in July, and within the next nine months 32 deaths had accumulated in the ward. The show is careful not to turn the situation into easy certainty, because sudden deaths in a children's hospital are not unheard of. Still, the spike in deaths made the ward impossible to ignore. A later case from 1981 adds another layer. An eighteen-week-old baby died with a drug in her system that slowed her heart rate, and the level found was nearly thirty times the recommended therapeutic dose. A nurse was initially taken into custody. The case fell apart at the preliminary hearing, yet the judge still believed somebody else might have been murdering children at the hospital. Another nurse later drew suspicion, but no charges were ever laid. The episode suggests that Smith may have seen these deaths and the police investigation up close, which could have shaped his own sense of mission. It then follows the 2005 chief coroner's review that grew out of troubling Ontario cases and mounting concerns about the reliability of Smith's forensic conclusions. The show closes by focusing on the harm that follows when expert claims are treated as final instead of checked against the record. Its anger is plain, and the point is clear: families paid the price for a system that took too long to question its own certainty.

As heard by us

A careful account of how forensic authority hardened into harm, and why the record still matters.

A Whole Life Later follows Charles Smith from an unsettled childhood and a long search for his birth mother to the authority he later held as a forensic child pathologist at Sick Kids.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a case study in how expert certainty can fail.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from A Whole Life Later