A Whole Life Later · Wrongful Convictions Collective

6 - Tammy Wynne (Marquardt) pt 1

October 18, 2024·50 min·15 clips

Tammy Wynn is going about her day when she thinks she hears her toddler calling from the spare room. She goes to check on Kenneth and finds him thrashing with a sheet wrapped around his neck. She tries to pry him free, but it does not end quickly. She calls 911 and pleads for help. The episode notes that Tammy is known in much of the media by her former married name, Marquardt. It also says she has returned to using that last name and now lives in New York City. The story is framed as part of Season 2, Ties That Bind. The narration stays measured and chronological. Kenneth is taken to Oshawa General Hospital with a spiral fracture in his femur. The episode pauses to explain what a spiral fracture is and why twisting force matters. It also points out that a two-year-old's bones are still developing and can break more easily than an adult might assume. Tammy's own experience is used to help explain why the injury should not be read too simply. The story lingers on the discomfort of the hospital course. Kenneth spends the next month in traction so the bone can heal in alignment. Tammy stays with him nearly every day, missing only three. When he is discharged on October 6, 1993, the doctor prescribes children's Tylenol for pain. Tammy hesitates to give it because of what she knows from her own experience. Kenneth is already taking epilepsy medication three times a day. The episode explains that phenobarbital had made him hyperactive, so he had been switched to dilantin. His seizures had not stopped. The narration recalls an earlier serious seizure after his first birthday, when he fell, hit his head on a toolbox, and was taken to SickKids. That earlier episode was treated as fine at the time, which makes the later developments harder to ignore. The episode keeps moving through the history in a plain, record-like way. It points out how medical facts accumulate and how easily they can be reworked once investigators start looking for blame. The case is not presented as neat or tidy. It is presented as painful, contested, and still unfolding. The episode also comments on source material, citing John Chipman's book Death in the Family while noting uncertainty about where the money goes. It warns listeners away from another book about Tammy's story. The final stretch brings in the pressure of an investigation and ends on the emotional force of being told the test was failed. Part one closes there, with the story clearly not finished.

As heard by us

A careful wrongful-conviction story that treats medical detail as part of the case, not decoration.

The episode begins with a parent hearing something alarming, finding her child in distress, and calling 911 without hesitation. From there, it moves through the injury, the hospital stay, and the medical history around a young child with epilepsy, and those details do the heavy…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a wrongful-conviction story that starts with a nap-time emergency and turns on medical detail.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from A Whole Life Later