A Whole Life Later · Wrongful Convictions Collective

11 - Greg Parsons

November 22, 2024·48 min·20 clips

Greg Parsons spends January 2, 1991, trying to reach his mother after New Year's Eve. He had seen her for about twenty minutes that afternoon, but she did not answer the door the day before and never picked up his calls. When the silence starts to feel wrong, he goes back to the apartment. The front window gets knocked out so he can get inside. The dog is the first clue. It barks and leads him upstairs. The bathroom door is locked, and Greg punches the lock open. He finds his mother dead and covered in blood. From there, the episode moves back into his life and the family history that shaped the case. Gregory Parsons was born on September 19, 1971, in St. John's, Newfoundland, to Jacob and Catherine Parsons. He was the second of two children, with an older brother named Todd. The narration says this family information comes from the Lammer Report and is vital to understanding the circumstances of Greg's life and wrongful conviction. His parents separated when he was six years old. The episode then shifts from the discovery scene to the police response. Greg says that once the cruiser door closed, the mind games started. He describes mental abuse that turned into torture as officers kept him at the station for hours. He says he was stripped down to his underwear and made to hold out his hands. The interrogation falls into a bad cop, good cop routine. One constable tells Greg that his answers sound truthful. Sergeant Singleton storms in with accusations about a sick bastard who would kill and rape his mother. The episode notes that it is not yet clear whether Catherine Carroll had been raped. That uncertainty matters, and the show does not brush past it. Around 10:45 PM, Greg's lawyer, Robert Simmons, arrives. He makes it clear that his client is invoking the right to silence. The lawyer leaves, and officers then go to the lawyer in the station and get permission to keep questioning Greg anyway. Greg says he keeps repeating that he is exercising his right to remain silent and that he is begging them to put him in jail. The night keeps getting colder and meaner. Greg says he is eventually given a white paper suit and oversized police boots with no laces, then handcuffed behind his back again. It is already 2:20 AM when he is forced to walk up the hill from the station to the lockup. He describes a freezing Newfoundland winter night with snow up to his waist. He says he was falling face first into the snow while officers laughed at him. The episode ends by telling listeners that the Lammer Report will come later, not today.

As heard by us

A grim, careful account of grief, coercion, and procedural failure.

Greg Parsons's story begins with a son breaking into his mother's apartment after days of silence and finding her dead. A Whole Life Later uses that discovery to frame a wrongful conviction case, and it keeps a steady hand without softening the police conduct that follows.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a wrongful-conviction story that opens on a mother's locked bathroom door and a son forcing his way inside.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from A Whole Life Later