A Modern Nonprofit Podcast · The Charity CFO, LLC

Episode 142: Why It’s So Hard to Trust Marketing Numbers (and What Nonprofits Can Do About It)

·36 min·2 clips

Jeff says the key metric is impressions, not clicks, because impressions are the closest measure of attention.

1. A Modern Nonprofit Podcast episode 142 examines why marketing numbers are hard to trust and what nonprofits can do about it. 2. Tasha Anderson is the host and managing partner of The Charity CFO, and Jeff Greenfield is the CEO and founder of Provalytics, which works on marketing tracking and data. 3. The episode asks what nonprofit leaders should measure when clicks, donations, and awareness do not line up cleanly. 4. Jeff says the marketing ecosystem changed after COVID and the lockdown because privacy made the old full-funnel tracking much harder. 5. He contrasts click tracking with the awareness work that happens before someone visits a website. 6. Tasha connects that problem to nonprofit boards that want to know whether marketing is actually working. 7. The discussion uses the John Wanamaker line about not knowing which half of advertising is wasted as a reference point. 8. Tasha describes nonprofit websites that have multiple audiences, including donors, board members, volunteers, and program participants. 9. She quotes a nonprofit leader who said, “I want their name, or I want their money, or I want both.” 10. Jeff says nonprofits need a business mindset and should test things like donation-button color and website mechanics. 11. He gives an estimate that button color changes can affect donations by 50% to 80% when traffic is high enough. 12. Jeff separates working media from non-working dollars and says staff costs belong in a different bucket than paid advertising. 13. He uses direct mail as an example of spending $5,000 and expecting a historical return pattern, then reevaluating if the return falls short. 14. Jeff says YouTube is now the number one television network in the U.S. for the last almost seven months, and he uses that to show how media habits have shifted. 15. He argues that Facebook and Instagram fit older audiences better, while TikTok and YouTube matter more for younger groups. 16. Later, Jeff says AI is already changing ad creation, including tools that can auto-generate ads from a business website. 17. He describes a future where AI can swap creative elements in real time, such as replacing a dog with a cat in an ad based on the viewer. 18. The tone is practical and conversational, with Tasha pressing for nonprofit examples and Jeff answering in business and media terms. 19. Listeners running nonprofit marketing, budgeting, or fundraising teams would get the most from it. 20. Listeners expecting a deep social-media tactics class or a pure fundraising case study may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from A Modern Nonprofit Podcast