Bernard Beitman: Connecting With Coincidence

The episode opens with the host narrating three historical coincidences: the 1911 Greenberry Hill murder, the 1983 Delmar Darien firefighter incident, and the 1958 Sidney Barringer suicide-homicide. Dr. Bernard Beitman is introduced as the first psychiatrist since Carl Jung to systematize coincidence study. Beitman explains why he uses 'coincidence' over 'synchronicity' for neutrality and broader accessibility. He shares a personal story of choking simultaneously with his father's death, calling it simulpathity. Beitman discusses various explanations for coincidences, including statistics, God, and human agency. He critiques statisticians' 'law of very large numbers' as vague and dismissive. Beitman introduces his concept of the psychosphere, a mental atmosphere around Earth where coincidences might occur. The conversation touches on apophenia and confirmation bias in interpreting patterns. Beitman outlines uses of coincidences, such as confirmation, decision-making, and romance, with examples like a couple reading Khalil Gibran. He warns against overinterpreting coincidences in relationships. The host and Beitman explore symbolic pointers and the role of emotion, particularly love, in facilitating coincidences. Beitman mentions his 'coincidence songs' and radio show. The episode concludes with references to the Sync Book and coincider.com.

As heard by us

A chain of uncanny deaths leads into a theory of shared mental atmosphere.

Coincidence becomes the episode's working climate: not proof of a hidden order, but a pressure system in which isolated oddities begin to feel arranged.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Three hanged men, a scuba diver in a tree, and psychic weather: your kind of rabbit hole?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify