Bridge of Lies: The Accomplice

April 8, 2026·35 min·3 clips

Preston Taylor described throwing his high school prom date's body off a bridge into the Shark River with no tears and no remorse.

A warning comes before the story gets going. The episode flags graphic descriptions, then moves to Neptune City, New Jersey, a few blocks from Sarah Stern's house. Police are already outside a bluish-gray two-bedroom house where two young men live. One has a two o'clock class at Brookdale Community College. That detail matters because the story moves step by step: surveillance, interview, then a return to the scene. Preston becomes the focus. Investigators press him on whether he backed Liam's plan because money might come from it. He says he did not really think about it. His account is guarded and says more about his own exposure than about Sarah. The questions get sharper. Detective Weisbrot asks how Preston feels about everything that happened to Sarah, and the answer has no visible grief. No emotions, no tears, no remorse are described. Preston says he thinks about what it means if investigators come back to him. Liam stays at the center of it. Preston says Liam convinced him the cover-up would hold for a while. The interview runs nearly two hours. When it ends, investigators say a prosecutor will decide what charge Preston may face. They still are not done. Next, they take Preston back to Sarah's house and have him show how Liam carried out the murder and covered it up. The episode is strongest as procedure. It listens to Preston explain himself, then follows detectives from the interview room back toward the scene.

As heard by us

A restrained police-led account that lands best in the interview and return-to-scene beats.

Bridge of Lies: The Accomplice stays strongest when it leans into procedure. The police pressure around Sarah Stern's killing, the surveillance outside a Neptune City house, and the careful questioning of Preston give the episode a steady shape, while his flat, remorse-free…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a cold, methodical accomplice interview after a surveillance build.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from 20/20 (ABC News)