1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries Podcast · Jon Hagadorn Podcast Host

THE RUSSIAN FISHING EXPEDITION & OTHER URBAN LEGENDS (URBAN LEGENDS #11)

·49 min·3 clips
Lake Ronkonkoma is linked to more than 160 drownings and a legend about a princess in the water.
1. 1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories, and Mysteries Podcast uses the episode title "The Russian Fishing Expedition & Other Urban Legends #11" to move from Cornwall to New York and Tennessee. 2. Host John Hagedorn narrates the episode and repeatedly cites newspapers, government reports, and folklore books as his source material. 3. The episode asks whether urban legends such as Bodmin Moor's big cat, the 27 Club, Lake Ronkonkoma, and the Bell Witch contain any traceable evidence. 4. For the Beast of Bodmin Moor, Hagedorn cites 1978 livestock mutilations in Cornwall and later BBC News footage from July 21, 1998. 5. He says the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, or MAFF, commissioned ADAS in January 1995 to investigate reports of big cats on Bodmin Moor. 6. The ADAS consultants Simon Baker and Charlie Wilson worked with an £8,200 budget and examined carcasses, tracks, photos, and video supplied by farmers and witnesses. 7. The investigation's written conclusion was that there was "no verifiable evidence for the presence of a big cat" and "no significant threat to livestock." 8. Hagedorn also quotes the ministry saying that 16 big cats had escaped into the wild since 1977, including lions, tigers, leopards, jaguars, and pumas. 9. The Siberian fishing story centers on two friends, a new pickup truck with caterpillar tracks, and 12 sticks of dynamite bought from a mine worker. 10. Their Malamute grabs the lit dynamite, runs it back toward the truck, and the blast sends the vehicle through the ice. 11. Hagedorn says the pair survive the winter hike out with the dog, but the truck remains in the deepest lake in Russia. 12. The 27 Club section names Brian Jones, Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin, Jim Morrison, Kurt Cobain, Amy Winehouse, Jonathan Brandes, Anton Yelchin, and Jean-Michel Basquiat. 13. Hagedorn says the age-27 death theory has been refuted by a University Academics study published in the British Medical Journal in December 2011. 14. He adds that the study found equally small increases at ages 25 and 32 and suggested that fame, not age 27 itself, raises risk. 15. The episode also mentions a 2014 Conversation article arguing that popular musicians were more likely to die at age 56 than at 27. 16. Hagedorn connects the club to songs by Fall Out Boy, John Craigie, and Eric Burdon, showing how the idea persists in music culture. 17. Lake Ronkonkoma is described as Long Island's largest and deepest lake and as the site of more than 160 recorded drownings. 18. The legend centers on Tuscawanta, Hugh Birdsall, and a seven-year pattern in which the lake is said to rise and fall with the princess's grief. 19. The Bell Witch segment shifts into a more documentary style with John Bell Sr., Betsy Bell, Joshua Gardner, Andrew Jackson, and Martin V. Ingram. 20. Listeners who like folklore, local history, and evidence-based ghost stories will get the most from this episode; listeners wanting a tight single-story narrative may skip it.

As heard by us

Urban legends are framed as folklore, then carried into the 27 Club and the stories that kept it alive.

This episode treats urban legends as folklore that claims truth without proof, then follows that idea into the Beast of Bodmin Moor and the history around the 27 Club.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want creepy folklore with a skeptical eye and a hard stop at the 27 Club.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on