1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries Podcast · Jon Hagadorn Podcast Host

BETRAYAL ON THE THAMES: THE FINAL DAYS OF POCAHONTAS

·23 min
In June of 1616, a ship named the Treasurer dropped anchor in the harbor of Plymouth, England, with Pocahontas, her husband John Rolfe, their infant son Thomas, and a retinue of over a dozen Powhatan men and women, and the arrival is framed as a diplomatic mission with English hopes attached to it. She was not alone. To the English, she is Lady Rebecca Rolfe, the Christianized daughter of an emperor; to her own people, she is Amunut, the daughter of Wahun Sikana, the Powhatan Paramount Chief, and the episode keeps both identities in view as it moves between the English court and Virginia. Her visit has a purpose. She meets with King James and Queen Anne, raises an endowment for a fledgling Indian school in Virginia, and meets with John Smith again, a man she had admired very much and for whom she grieved deeply when the English in Virginia told her that he had died. The story does not polish the colony. It points to the Virginia Company's need for investment, the English urge to prove the New World could be controlled, and the larger colonial habit of using her life as proof of what England wanted to believe. Her death stays uncertain. The episode says she never made it back home, notes the familiar London air explanation, and then turns to Mattaponi oral tradition, which believes Captain Argyle poisoned her on the ship that was meant to take her back. Smith is pulled back in. His own story is treated with skepticism as the narration revisits the gunpowder accident that tore into his thigh and asks whether it was really an accident. He was unpopular. During the starving winter at Jamestown, the episode paints him as a hard taskmaster who famously declared, He that will not work shall not eat. But this did not sit well with the gentlemen who wanted status without labor, except when it came to shoveling tons of gold mud into the hull of a ship that was to return to England. Only they found out later, there was no gold in the mud. Legend and some historical theory suggests that Smith's detractors, men like George Percy and Ratcliffe, saw an opportunity to rid themselves of the soldier of fortune. The accident happened while Smith was asleep on a boat. It is whispered that a slow match was only applied to his pouch. If he died, they were rid of a tyrant. If he lived, he would be too maimed to lead and forced to sail for London for medical attention. Smith survived, but he left Virginia in a shroud of secrecy. When Pocahontas asked about her brother, Captain Smith, the English settlers told her he was dead. The reasons were purely political. The leaders of Jamestown wanted to break her emotional tie to Smith and redirect her life to the world of the British, and eventually to the Christian God and John Rolfe. If she knew Smith was alive and had simply abandoned her and her father, it might have sparked a war. By killing him off, it made him a martyr in her eyes, ensuring she remained a friend to the English rather than a young woman scorned by a specific man. In review, there is probably a lot more to the story of Pocahontas than we learned in history class. Pocahontas was used by the English as a tool for propaganda, but she was so much more. She was a diplomat who navigated two worlds that were destined to clash. She wasn't a girl who gave up her culture for a man. She was a woman who sacrificed her safety to ensure her people's survival through diplomacy. She remains a symbol of the American origin story, a reminder that before the war and conflict, there was a brief, shining moment of attempt at understanding.

As heard by us

A colonial era story that treats Pocahontas as a diplomat, not a legend.

The episode works best when it treats Pocahontas as a diplomatic figure, not a legend. It moves cleanly from Plymouth to the royal court and brings in John Rolfe, John Smith, the Virginia Company, and the politics around her visit.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A 1616 Pocahontas story that turns a famous visit into a diplomatic mission and a Virginia Company pitch.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on